8/19/2019 d8.cabrera v. ca

1/8

G.R. No. 108547February 3, 1997

FELICIDAD VDA. DE CABRERA, MAR!ANE CABRERA a"# FELICIDAD $E%&EMIAN,'e()()o"er*, +*.C%R$ %F A--EAL a"# VIRGILIA %RAI DE FELICI%, re're*e"(e# by /er A((or"ey)"Fa(,ERNE$% M. %RAI, re*'o"#e"(*.

$%RRE, !R., !.2

 A**a)e# )" (/)* -e()()o" or Re+)e o" Cer()orar) )* (/e De)*)o" 1 o (/e re*'o"#e"( Cour( o  A''ea* #a(e# !a"uary 7, 1993 )" CAG.R. No. 66407CV, (/e #)*'o*)()+e 'or()o" o /)/ rea#*2

EREF%RE, (/e #e)*)o" o (/e oer our( )* /ereby REVERED a"# u#:;e"( )* /erebye"(ere# or#er)": #ee"#a"(* Fe))#a# V#a. #e Cabrera a"# Mary?u)e()": o $)(e (oRea -ro'er(y, Da;a:e* )(/ -re);)"ary I"u"()o".> $/e (r)a our(@* #)*'o*)()o" rea#*2

EREF%RE, (/e 'a)"()= )* /ereby or#ere#2

a (o eeu(e a reo"+eya"e )(/)" (/)r(y 30 #ay* a(er (/)* #e)*)o" */a /a+e beo;e"a a"# eeu(ory )" a+or o #ee"#a"( Fe))#a# V#a. De Cabrera orre*'o"#)": o"y (o (/a('or()o" o Lo( No. 6639 a(uay a"# '/y*)ay 'o**e**e# a"# ou')e# by (/e #ee"#a"( a**ee" ro; (/e *

8/19/2019 d8.cabrera v. ca

2/8

by a Cer()a()o" o a" o=)er)"/ar:e o (/e %=)e o (/e Cer< o Cour(, R$C, Br. 7,Ba:a":a, Da+ao %r)e"(a E/. 4. Fe))#a# Cabrera a"# /er /u*ba"# );;e#)a(ey (oo?u)e()": o $)(e (o Rea -ro'er(y, Da;a:e*)(/ -re);)"ary Ma"#a(ory I"u"()o".>

$/e o;'a)"(, /)/ a* a;e"#e# o" !u"e 66, 1988 by )"u#)": Fe))#a# $eoEREF%RE, (/)* o"orabe Cour(, a(er #ue "o()e a"# /ear)": o" (/e ;er)(* o (/)* a*e

8/19/2019 d8.cabrera v. ca

3/8

(o )**ue or#er or or#er*

1. F)"#)": (/e #ee"#a"(* a* (/e r):/(u, au, a"# e:a o"er o (/a( 'or()o" /)/ a**o# (o (/e; by Fe))#a# $eo

8/19/2019 d8.cabrera v. ca

4/8

F)r*(. $/e Dee# o Ab*ou(e ae #a(e# May 67, 1976 E/. 3 eeu(e# by Aber(a"a$eo. or*e, (/e *u''o*e# +e"#ee, Ea"o Cabrera, a"# /er*ue**or*)")"(ere*(, #ee"#a"(* Fe))#a# +#a. #e Cabrera a"# Mary(/eor):)"a o"er@* r):/( (o reo+er ba< (/e 'o**e**)o" o (/e 'ro'er(y a"# ()(e (/ere(o ro; (/e#ee"#a"( /a* by (/e o": 'er)o# o 37 year* a"# by (/e 'a(e"(ee@* )"a()o" a"# "e:e( bee"o"+er(e# )"(o a *(ae #e;a"#.>

La/e*, )" a :e"era *e"*e, )* a)ure or "e:e(, or a" u"rea*o"abe a"# u"e'a)"e# e":(/ o ();e, (o #o (/a( /)/, by (/e eer)*e o #ue #)):e"e, ou# or */ou# /a+e bee" #o"e ear)er)( )* "e:):e"e or o;)**)o" (o a**er( a r):/( )(/)" a rea*o"abe ();e, arra"()": a're*u;'()o" (/a( (/e 'ar(y e"()(e# (o a**er( )( $)a; +*. )bo":/a"oy, 36 CRA 69. )"e);'re*r)'()b))(y )* o"e o (/e ba*) ea(ure* o a $orre"* ()(e, )( )* "o( a" or#)"ary #eay )"a**er()": o"e@* r):/( (/a( ) :)+e r)*e (o (/e a'')a()o" o (/e 'r)")'e o a/e*, o(/er)*e,re:)*(ere# ()(e a" ea*)y be #eea(e# by 're*r)'()o". $/)* )* 're)*ey (/e rea*o" /y, )" (/ea*e* )(e#, (/e #eay or )"a()o" by (/e re:)*(ere# o"er* )" a**er()": (/e)r r):/(* a*o"*)#ere# u"rea*o"abe a"# u"e'a)"e# beau*e )( (oo< (/e; ro; 36 (o 37 year* (o #o *o. I"o"(ra*(, (/e #eay )" (/e a*e a( bar a* o"y our(ee" year*.

/)e 'o**e**)o" o #ee"#a"(* Fe))#a# +#a. De Cabrera a"# Mary

8/19/2019 d8.cabrera v. ca

5/8

)*(er* Fe))#a# V#a. #e Cabrera a"# Mary(/e re:)*(ra()o" o (/e 'a)"()=@*()(e o+er (/e *ube( 'ro'er(y a* rau#ue"( )"*oar a* )( )"+o+e# (/e o"e(/)r# )"(ere*( o 

Fe))#a# $eo

8/19/2019 d8.cabrera v. ca

6/8

>B> ) a((e*( (o (/e a( (/a( */e #)# "o( *e /er */are )" (/e o( )" Hue*()o". A(er (/)* *ae(/e +e"#ee A"#re* %ra)* (/rou:/ /)* e"ar:a#o Mee)o Ca'))(a" a"# a(er er+)a"o Abara);;e#)a(ey (oo< 'o**e**)o" o (/e (o (/)r# 'or()o" o *a)# 'are o a"# re*'e()": (/e (/)r#'or()o" o"e# by Fe))#a# $eo

8/19/2019 d8.cabrera v. ca

7/8

 +#a. De Cabrera a"# /er a(e /u*ba"# /a+e bee" a()+ey )" 'o**e**)o" o (/e *a;e, ())": )(,a"# o"*(ru()": a" )rr):a()o" *y*(e; (/ereo". $/)* ;u*( *urey o"*()(u(e *u/ (ar#)"e** o"(/e 'ar( o (/e 'a)"()= o"*()(u()": (/e ba*)* or a/e*.

La/e* /a* bee" #e"e# a* (/e a)ure or "e:e(, or a" u"rea*o"abe a"# u"e'a)"e# e":(/o ();e, (o #o (/a( /)/ by eer)*)": #ue #)):e"e ou# or */ou# /a+e bee" #o"e ear)er, )()* "e:):e"e or o;)**)o" (o a**er( a r):/( )(/)" a rea*o"abe ();e, arra"()": a 're*u;'()o"(/a( (/e 'ar(y e"()(e# (o a**er( )( e)(/er /a* aba"#o"e# )( or #e)"e# (o a**er( )(. 17 $/e

#ee"*e o a/e* )* a" eHu)(abe o"e a"# #oe* "o( o"er" )(*e )(/ (/e /ara(er o (/e#ee"#a"(* ()(e, bu( o"y )(/ /e(/er or "o( by rea*o" o 'a)"()=* o": )"a()o" or)"eu*abe "e:e(, /e */ou# be barre# ro; a**er()": /)* a); a( a, beau*e (o ao /);(o #o *o ou# be )"eHu)(abe a"# u"u*( (o #ee"#a"(. La/e* )* "o( o"er"e# ;erey )(/a'*e o ();e, u")

8/19/2019 d8.cabrera v. ca

8/8

 A* eary a* 1963, (/)* Cour( /a* rue# (/a( e+e" ) a oo"er *e* (/e /oe 'ro'er(y a* /)*,(/e *ae ) a=e( o"y /)* o" */are bu( "o( (/o*e o (/e o(/er oo"er* /o #)# "o( o"*e"((o (/e *ae -u"aa" +*. Boo" L)a(, 44 -/) 360 1963. $/)* )* beau*e u"#er (/eaore;e"()o"e# o#a 'ro+)*)o", (/e *ae or o(/er #)*'o*)()o" a=e(* o"y /)* u"#)+)#e# */area"# (/e (ra"*eree :e(* o"y /a( ou# orre*'o"# (o /)* :ra"(or )" (/e 'ar()()o" o (/e (/)":*o"e# )" o;;o" Ra;)re +*. Bau()*(a, 14 -/) 568 1909. . . . For Ar()e 494 o (/e C)+)Co#e e'))(y #eare*2 >No 're*r)'()o" */a )e )" a+or o a oo"er or o/e)r *o o": a*/e e're**y or );')e#y reo:")e* (/e oo"er*/)'. 66

IN VIE ERE%F, (/e 'e()()o" )* /ereby GRAN$ED. $/e #e)*)o" o (/e Cour( o A''ea*#a(e# !a"uary 7, 1993 )* /ereby E$ AIDE. $/e #e)*)o" o (/e (r)a our( #a(e# A'r) 67,1989 )* /ereby REIN$A$ED )" (o(o.

% %RDERED.