Post on 02-Mar-2018
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
1/70
INDICE
LA SERVIDUMBRE EN EL CODIGO CIVIL Y EN EL DERECHO
INTERNACIONAL PRIVADO Y ANALISIS JURISPRUDENCIAL CON
RELACION A LA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
INTRODUCCION 04
CAPITULO I: PLANTEAMIENTO DEL PROBLEMA 06
1.1. DETERMINACION DEL PROBLEMA 06
1.2. OBJETIVOS DE LA INVESTIGACION 071.3. JUSTIFICACION Y MOTIVACION DE LA INVESTIGACION 071.4. HIPOTESIS VARIABLES Y MOTIVACION 0!
CAPITULO II: LA SERVIDUMBRE EN EL CODIGO CIVIL Y
EL CODIGO BUSTAMANTE 0"
2.1. LA SERVIDUMBRE EN EL CODIGO CIVIL 0"2.2. LA SERVIDUMBRE EN EL CODIGO BUSTAMANTE 21
CAPITULO III: LA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA 323.1. GENERALIDADES 32
3.2. DEFINICI#N 33
3.3. NATURALE$A JUR%DICA 3&
3.4. CARACTER%STICAS DE LA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA 36
3.&. DERECHOS DEL DUE'O DEL PREDIO DOMINANTE Y
DEL DUE'O DEL PREDIO SIRVIENTE 3"
3.6. PROCEDIMIENTO PARA LA OBTENCION DE LASERVIDUMBRE MINERA EN EL PERU 40
3.7. DERECHO A LA SOLICITUD DE LA SERVIDUMBRE
MINERA 47
CAPITULO IV: TRABAJO DE CAMPO Y RESULTADOS:
INVESTIGACION JURISPRUDENCIAL SOBRE
2
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
2/70
LA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA &0
4.1. TRABAJO DE INVESTIGACION 1 &0
4.2. TRABAJO DE INVESTIGACION 2 &!
CONCLUSIONES 6!
RECOMENDACIONES 6"
BIBLIOGRAF%A 70
INTRODUCCIN
3
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
3/70
E( )*+),-/+ ( -/5, 8- )*)+ +)/8(9* (
S*8* ( C,5+ C( ; ( C,5+ B8-// )* )*/* + (+- *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
4/70
(+ 8 - + Servidumbre Minera -/(+ 8 (+8 +*/+
8 ?(/ +?58* ( >/+ @8*=+ ( 8 - -**+(( ( /
( /8, ( E-/+ (+- +)*+*- ; ( +8 5*(.
L +*59, ( )*+;/+ -/5, -/> +-//8+ 8/*+
)=/8(+-:
E ( )** )=/8(+ Planteamiento el P!o"lema# Dete!mina$ion el
P!o"lema# O"%eti&o e la In&e'ti(a$ion# J)'ti*i$a$ion# Moti&a$ion e la
In&e'ti(a$ion# Hi+ote'i'# Va!ia"le' , Metoolo(ia-
E ( -58+ )=/8(+ La Se!&i)m"!e en el C.i(o Ci&il , el C.i(o
B)'tamante- - )9 + ( *+ +)/8( ( -*8*
/+ ++ 5* 8 (/ ( )*+) /+ (. A>- (-- ( -*8* ( C,5+ B8-//.
E ( /** )=/8(+Se!&i)m"!e Mine!a- - -**+(( -8- //- (
?, */*=-/- +(8, ( (5-(, )*8 ; (
)*+/+ )* +-//8*(.
E 8 8*/+ )=/8(+ Anali'i' J)!i'+!)en$ial e la Se!&i)m"!e Mine!a-
C+--/ 8 /*@+ )+ ( 8( - )( ( /++ --/>/+ ?/+- /*@* )*)(/ -+* (+- +- 8 -8?** (
(5-(, )* 8*( ( *(.
5
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
5/70
CAPITULO I/ PLANTEAMIENTO DEL PROBLEMA
0101 DETERMINACION DEL PROBLEMA
P*((/ (+- 5*-+- +,+- >- ?8*/- 8 * ( E-/+
P*8+ +**-)+ (+- )*+8+- )+* ( / *. S+ -= -
?=( )-* 8 ( P* )+*= )*-* ( *=. T)++ - )+-(
*/* ( *-5+ ( )=- )8- )+*= 5** 8 ++ )/(- 8
((*= ( ( ( )=-. P+* ((+ )++- ?** 8 ( )*+( -
(/)( ; 8 ( E-/+ + )8 -8* 8 )+-/8* @ ((+ )8- //+
(+- )*+(- -+(- ++ +,+- ( +)/. E( + )+*= -* (
*/+*+ (+- +)/+- -*8* * 8 -/( ( +/* -*5+ -/+ + -+(8+*= ( )*+( )* (+- )+(+*- )-+-.
A--+ (* ( -*8* * ; (/* *-
++ + /**- *9- -*= -/* ( / *.
89>- - 8 ?+* (9* ( / ( -*8* * ** 8
--/ +(, >- ?/+ 8 ( -/(+ )+* ( D*,
G*( M*= 8 )8 +/** 8 -+(8, 8 + ?/ 58 (- )*/- +@8/+ 8 --/ -/*/+ ?/+ +
-/ 8 @+ 8+ ,+ )* ( )(, ( S*8*
M*. D (+ +/**+ ( P* @*> -* ( )* /+- (- *-+-
+(- ; /*@*- ; - *-, )*+- /++-.
L )*-/ -/5, - *(9, /++ ++ *?* ( */8(+ (
C,5+ C( + ( S*8* ( )*+),-/+ ( -/5,+--/, (9* ( +*/ -+* ( /* ; /** -
?8/ 8/ (- -+- @8*-+(- +
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
6/70
0121 OBJETIVOS DE LA INVESTIGACION
012101 OBJETIVO GENERAL
D/** - ( J8*-)*8 -+* S*8* M* -/> /
-8-// ( +*/ -+* S*8* ( C,5+ C( ; ( C,5+
B8-//.
012121 OBJETIVOS ESPECI3ICOS
D-** ( S*8* ( C,5+ C( ; ( C,5+ B8-//.
D-** ( /*//+ ( S*8* M* ( +*/ ( )=-.
A>(-- @8*-)*8 / )+* ( T*8( C+-//8+( -+* (
S*8* M*.
D/** ( 5 ( +*/ -+* ( S*8* M* (--+- ( >+ T*8( J8-/ ( )=-.
0141 JUSTI3ICACION Y MOTIVACION DE LA INVESTIGACION
014101 JUSTI3ICACION
L )+*/ ( )*-/ -/5, * )*)(/ /*
8 8+ - +/+*5 ( //8(* *+ *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
7/70
/+- ( ++ ++ ( *= )+* -8 (/+ (+* ( *+ ;
)+* +/*+ +- +/*+- + ( */+ /+ /*- (
+-*, *(9 /*- -/*8/+- (5(- 8 +(8*
/- )*-.
E -/ +//+ (+- )*+(- -8*5 8+ +- /*-- -
-8)*)+ - 8 )8 )*(5*- 8 / -+* ( +/* ; 8
- *-8(/ /*- )* ( E-/+. A-= /+- 8 (+- +-+*+-
*+- 8/ + (
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
8/70
CAPITULO II/ MARCO TEORICO
2101 LA SERVIDUMBRE EN EL CODIGO CIVIL
210101 Etimolo(6a1
S 8*+- +/** 8 +*5 /+(,5+ ( /*+ -*8* (+
)++- +/** ( (/ -*/8+ + -*/8*- 8 -* + -5?*
+, -*+ -(/8 -8-, 5*.
E ( D*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
9/70
+, ?8+ -*/ ?+* + )*+) -/ ?8+ ?8+
+/.
D (+- //+- *++- - 8 /*- *5(- )*)(- +* (-
-*8*- )*(-2.
1 N *- -8 -*/. E- * ( -*8* -+ 8 *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
10/70
L S*8* /*+- 5*(- ( D*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
11/70
E( +)/+ -*8* * -)(/ ( D*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
12/70
(5/, -/ +)+*- ( //8(* ( *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
13/70
*e"&) CL"s ser#d/$bres re"les E&% 0*E'% Le#o&es de
*ere!o ##l) 9/e&os A#res; Ed##o&es G/r?d#"s E/ro"A$
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
14/70
((+- - / 8 * *-)/+ ( +, ( )*+ -*/ 8
8/ + 5* ; ( ( )*+ +/ 8 / ( ?+ 8- (+- )*+- + )8+ -***-
((- + - )8 -)+* ((- @+ 5 /+ @8*=+
)// (+- )*+-.
E-/ +/*+- *ore E/eo; 0&st#t/#o&es de *ere!o ##l, .o$o 0, L#$"% S)E;1-52) +) 6-2)
15
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
15/70
L- -*8*- -+ *- -
)*-8 8 8 )*+ -/> (* -*8*-. D +?+* + (
)*)+ 5*( /+ )*+) - -8)+ (* /*- + - 8-/* 8
-+* (( )- ( -/ 8 5*. P+* ( 8 ?* (-/ )*+*( ((= ( )+*/ -8 -*), (+- *5-/*+-
)(+-.
2101
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
16/70
E-/ -/, /* (- -*8*- + *-)+ 8 (58- *-/
( */* -/*/+ + +*/+ ( -8@/+ 8
)*/ 8 -+ )+* ( ?( ( (58@ ((* -= ( 8;+
?+ - -/( ( -*8* )-* 8 *( ( //8(* -
( 8+ + )+-+* -89 R=+- L- -*8*- - (-? -
)*(- /**/+*(- + *(- ? ?**(- ( 8-8?*8/+ 8-+ ; (
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
17/70
8 -/8,
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
18/70
+/ 8* +/*+ 8 ( -( + 8+ - * 8 +
8 ( -+ /+
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
19/70
E( //8(* ( )*+ -*/ - ( )*+)/*+ ( -+ + -8@/+ )-+ 8
-+)+*/ ( (/, -//. T ++ ( -+ ( //8(* /+ -/
* )8(// *+ -5 - )*+89 (- /*--+- (
)*/8(* + 8*-(/20.
2101>1 O"%eto e la' 'e!&i)m"!e'
E-/- - (-? :
Se!&i)m"!e' +o'iti&a'1: S+ 8((- 8 )*/ ( )*+)/*+ ( )*+
+/ ( )+* *(9* /*+- /+- ( )*+ -*/. P+*
@)(+: (- -*8*- )-+ 88/+ /* +/*-21.
Se!&i)m"!e' ne(ati&a'1:S+ 8((- 8 ) (5+ )+ 8 +*. L
)+*/ -/ -*8* * )8- 8 *-/*, -* -8
*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
20/70
* ( -*8*. L +?8-, -/+- -+- - -8/ (
+/* /8( )8- - /*/ 8= 8 -*8* )*+)/*+.. P+* ( *8 ( 8+ ( )*+ +/ - * ( )*/ 8
+/ ( /@ ( -*8* ( *8 - ( )*//++(8/*+ 8 *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
21/70
-+(8, +?(/+- /*+(- -= ++ ( @89 8 *-+(*> -/
+/*+*- P+-, N+*/-/.
M+*/ ( +/* -/> +
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
22/70
/, ( 8*-+ - )+* /** ( 5*+ )+*/ 8 /
8 -/- ; -8- *-+- ?8/+-.
S5 ( E-//8/+ ( C+*/ I/*+( J8-/2&8* ++ ?8/-
(- -58/-:
LA DOCTRINA/
V -* ( +@8/+ (- +)+- (+- @8*-+-8(/+- -+* 8
/*+ -)/+ ( D*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
23/70
E- ( +@8/+ (;- ; -)+-+- 8 *5 8 (- *- (
D*
--//9- ?*>+- (- +*- -8-//- + /*(- (-
+*- 8 - 8/(9 )* )(* (- )**- - * (- (;- )*+-(-
+ / (- +*- +?(/8(- 8 -+ (- 8 - -( 8 (;
)(*- 8 -+ +*/+.
L5-(, I/*+(: L - ( *+- *-+- -)+- ++:
Le(i'la$i.n en Am!i$a Latina
A( 58( 8 E8*+) A* (/ )9 /++ 8 )*+-+ +-+*/+- ? 8?+*9* */*+- + *-)/+ 8 --/
/*+( *-8(/+ -+- )**+- )-+- +/*+- 8 5
++- -= /+-:
LA CONVENCION DE LIMA
D?// ?8 8+ ( )** )*+-+ (5-(* -)/+- *(++- (
D*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
24/70
TRATADO DE MONTEVIDEO
D-)8- 8 //+ ?*8-/*+ 1!!" - *(9, ( T*/+ M+/+
( 8( ?8 )*++ )+* )*/- - * - +-//8;, /*/+- )/-
-+ -)=?+ -= /+- 8 -/ T*/+ M+/+ +/
+ (+- -58/- /*/+-:
T*/+ D*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
25/70
8; )(, + - )8 (8*. L +), /8( (+ +-* ++
+ ?- ( +*/+ J8*=+.
212151 LA ESTRUCTURA DEL CODIGO DE BUSTAMANTE
E( C,5+ B8-// +-//8; ( )** //+ )+* +?* ( D*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
26/70
E( */=8(+ 4 (- -)+-+- + -8)*= +-//8+( 8 *>/*
/*+( )(+ (+ -+ 8 (- +*- -/(- )+* ( D* -8 )*+) (-?, (- -//8+- + *(+-
@8*=- 8
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
27/70
LIBRO SEGUNDO/ DERECHO MERCANTIL INTERNACIONAL/
A 8 ( 8+ -
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
28/70
R)*-//- D)(+>/+- (- +- )*/ (+- /**/+*+- (-
>- ; (- )*-+- -8 ?( 8 -8 +)= (8;+
-8- )(+- /*@*+-. E-/ (*+ 8 +/ 8 /=/8(+ + ; ( -
+* (- -58/- /*-:
. L- L;- P(-.
. D(/+- +/+- 8 E-/+ E/*@*+ C+/*//.
. D(/+- +/+- ?8* /++ T**/+*+ N+(.
. D-)+-+- G*(- * ( /.
LIBRO CUARTO/ DERECHO PROCESAL INTERNACIONAL/
O/ ; ++ /++ 8*)+ (;- /5*( -/ 8 )*/
-8-// 8 - ( +* (+- (*+- /*+*- ; 8 )*/ A@/ (
8 - /+ -/ )*/+ - * )* 5*/9* )(/ (
-58* @8*= (+- /*@*+- /**/+*+ /*@*+ 8 E-/+ P*/
* -*+ *58(* / ( * )*+*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
29/70
TITULO SEGUNDO/ DE LOS BIENES
CAPITULO VI/ De la' 'e!&i)m"!e'
A!t6$)lo 040
S )(*> ( *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
30/70
CAPITULO III/ SERVIDUMBRE MINERA1
4101 Gene!aliae'1
E( 85 ( / * 8 -/+- /*-+ /* ++
+-8 ( 8 /- ++ ( )*-/ /5 5* /8(. E ?/+
( +-** (- - ++ *8*-+- *(- + *+(- ;
+/*>+- ( ;+*= ( -8-8(+ ( /+ +-//8+( 8 (
/*8; ( )*+) (+- -+- ( E-/+ *-(/ + -+(+ -8 )+*/
)* ( */+ +,+ ; -+( ( )=- -+ 8 / *( (
/*- 5*( 8 / ( +8 *-)/+ - -8 @+ ;
)*+
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
31/70
/ ( - /+/( - -+* (+- /**+- -8)*?(- 8;-
/*- 8((- - 8/* -/8-. P+* (+ 8 (8( 8 ( *+
?/+ ( /*- ( )*+)/*+ -8)*?(.
S / ; (5( ( 9 )* (*
8(8* +?(/+ /* (- )*/- ; /* (+- /*)/+- ( -**+((+
+,+ 8(. S+ ( ++ (+- /**+- -8)*?(-
-//+- (+- ( +-, * ; 8+ -/+- -//+- /
(+- ( +/* +-, - ++ 8 -
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
32/70
8- 8/( )( + ( ? ?+** ( -**+((+ (+-
/*@+*- )(+*+- *-31
L +, )*+) ; -( ( -*8* * - 8 -/ -/
(8-/ ( )(+/, ; + )8 8/(9*- )*+),-/+ ?*/
)* (+ 8 ?8 +-//8+32.
E- 8( 5* *( 8;+ +*5 -/ ( L; 8*, (/ 8
- -/( -+* /**+- //+ )*+- ++ )(+- ?+* (
8-/* * ((- -/ +- )*/8(*- + ( E-/+ +
)(/8 -8?/ )* ?(/* ( /+/( )*+ +-//8* 8 -*8* )-+ )* * /**+-
)*+) +/*+- ; -= +*/* ( )*+;/+ ; (+5** ((5* ( )8*/+ +
)(/. L -*8* )8 -* ++( + (5( ( )** - 8((
8 - -/( 8/8+ 8*+ /* (- )*/- ; ( +/* -*> )8-/
/*- ( (;. L (, 8 8 +/* )*> ( +(8/ ( 8+
/**+ -*/ + -8*+ + ( - -/(* ?//
8 -*8*. S5 ( (5-(, )*8 ( 8/(9, /**- )* (@*+ /- *- + ore) #t"&do '"rt" SHl#" Vel"rde, '"&/"l de dere!o $#&ero9/e&os A#res,1-86) 2(6)32+AEO >0'E:EZ, 0s"?"s) *ere!o '#&ero de 9ol##") Ed##& #&""d" orl" B/&d"#& Uers#t"r#" CS#$& 0) +"t#Do L" +"F) 9ol##") 1-54) +) 413)33=O:ZALES9ER.0, L/?s) o$e&d#o de dere!o $#&ero Ve&eFol"&o) .o$o 0,.erer" ed##& "t/"l#F"d") +/bl#"#o&es de l" B"/lt"d de dere!o de l"Uers#d"d de los A&des) '
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
33/70
)*+/+ -*8*. E/+- )++- ?* ( -*8* ++
8 )*-+ 8-+ 8 +/+*5 ( 8/+* -+* 8 /**+ -*/ +
-8*+ ?+* 8 +-, * -+ + - * -+(/34
L -*8* * -+ 8 -+ ,+ )* +-58* (
)*+ +/- ( C)=/8(+ IV ( T=/8(+ D8++ ( T/+ +
O*+ TUO ( L; G*( M*= D*/+ S8)*+ 114"2EM.
T -+ )*//- (- +*- ( R5(/+ )+* D*/+ S8)*+
017"6 AG ; (- ( R5(/+ P*+/+- M*+-.
L- +*- -)(- + ? (- -*8*- *- *9, )+* ( 8(
+- *8*** ( ?, 5*(. A-= - /*/ 8 5* -+* 8
34
LA:AO Ed/"rdo) re" Le"l P S:'+E Re#st" *esde Ade&tro, Ed##& &/$) 2-,E&ero 2((6
34
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
34/70
)*+ )*+ -*/ 8 ( )*/ ( //8(* 8 +-, ( @*+
/- *- -= ++ )* ( /*-)+*/ *( )+* 8/+-. E
)** (85* 8 )8- 8
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
35/70
(/* ( 8( )*-/+- 8 +- -*/ ;
+/ - 8/* +(5+-3&.
B. C+-//8; 8 *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
36/70
E. P8 -* APARENTES + NO APERENTES -5 -8 -(.
A)*/- (- +*- 8 + )*-/ -5+- /*+*- -/.
L- )++- +-** +- /5+*=-:
S*8* -8)*?(-. T )+* ?( @8/* +*-
?*-/*8/8* * -,(+ ( -8)*?( ( >* ( +-,
/(- ++ /*+- +* 8 ( )*+ -*/ -
-8)*?( + -/ 8+ 8 -8-8(+. T )+*
+@/+ ( +-/*8, +-+- - (- (+*-
*8*- ; -*- )* ( -+ ( /(, -5 /.
(- - 8 -/ /( -*+.
F. L+- *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
37/70
/,. E-/ * (/- )+* ( *+( 8/(9,
(- +-+- * - 8 -8 -/(/+ )8 5**
*+- 8-- ( +-+*+. I. 3 A*/. 37 L; G*(
M*=
4191 DERECHOS DEL DUEO DEL PREDIO DOMINANTE Y DEL DUEO
DEL PREDIO SIRVIENTE1
3.&.1. E( )*+)/*+ ( 8( +/ / *os
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
38/70
E( +)/+ )*+ -8)*?( -*/ /* -*8* *
/ / ; -/*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
39/70
41+ /*/ 30 =-
(+*(- ( -+(// ( -*8* - *5 ( D*, G*(
M*= )++ ++/+ ( 5+//+ ( /) /*/+ */+
+)+ ( +-/ *), ( */ +/*( )+* ( )*+)/*+
( )*+.
E /( */8 ( D*, G*( M*= ((*> (- )*/- ; (- +*
+(* + ( )*/), 8 C/*+ C+(, -5+
+ 8*+ 8 )(9+ + ;+* 10 =- (+*(-. E -+
)*+8*- -/ 8*+ ( D*, G*( M*= -+(/*> (
D*, R5+( A5** ( @8*-, 8 /* ( 8( (5*> (C/*+ C+(, )* 8 8 )(9+ >+ 30 =- (+*(-
)*+89 ( 8*+ *-)/+ ( -*8*.
L C+(, - *58(* +?+* ( L; C+(, ; -8 R5(/+
; -*> -8?*5 )+* ( -+(// ( -*8* /*- ( D*,
G*( M*=.
L D*, G*( M*= *> -/*8* ( )*+)/*+ ( /**+
-8)*?( -+* ( (5-(, * ; -*8* (5( * -= ++-+* (+- * ( /-, ( >*
-+(/ (+*+ +(/ 8 ?+* /+ /
-8-//+ 8 ( - ( -*8* - )+-( - ** ( *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
40/70
(+ + )* - )*- - 1& =- (+*(- ; -*>
*/- ( C/*+ C+(, ; ( D*, G*( M*= )*
8 -* *?* + - -8- *-)/+- )*+/+-.44
41 +@/+
*/?, )+* )*/ ( C/*+ +(, +/?>+- ( D*,
G*( M*=.
C8( ( /) +(, - 8 - -+(/*- ( D*, G*( M*= ( + (
)*+/+ -/*/+ -*8* (5( @8/+ ( */
+/*( ( +*)+*>+- /+- ( )/ (+- *-)/+- ?+*-
)*(-4&.
41 ( )*-8/+ ?/*.
A+)*> 8 +* D-*)/ + ( /(( (- +*-
@8/*-46.
41
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
41/70
/*>/ -+ +8** ( )*+)/*+. E */* -8 *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
42/70
41+ 10 =- (+*(- +/?+ + (
R-+(8, @+ ) (**- + ( -+(/8.&2
41
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
43/70
S /*-8**+- (+- 10 =- (+*(- ( )*+)/*+ + ?*- ( -*/8*
)(- -/ -*> ?* *(= )+* ( D*/+* G*( M*=
-/*8;+ ( B+ ( N, )* /*5* ( +/+ +-5+ (
)*+)/*+.&3
41 * (- +*- )*
(- 8 ?8 -+(/.S ( 8/+* * +)*8 8 ( /* ( )*+), -
8/(9+ )* (+- ?- -//+- (+- -)=?/ -+(/+- )-*> -
+-/+ (58+ ++ ( E-/+ )* (+ 8( ( D*, G*( M*=
)*> ( *-+(8, *-)/ ( 8 -**> ( O? N+( (+-
R5-/*+- P(+- ; ( INGEMNET.&4
53Art?/lo 1I del *ereto S/re$o :I (152((3A=, $od#N"tor#" de "rt?/los delRel"$e&to delArt?/lo 7I de l" LeH :I 265(5, sobre roed#$#e&to "r" el est"ble#$#e&to deser#d/$bre le"l $#&er","rob"do or *ereto S/re$o :I (17-6A=)54Art?/lo 1I del *ereto S/re$o :I (152((3A=, $od#N"tor#" de "rt?/los delRel"$e&to del
Art?/lo 7I de l" LeH :I 265(5, sobre roed#$#e&to "r" el est"ble#$#e&to deser#d/$bre le"l $#&er", "rob"do or *ereto S/re$o :I (17-6A=)
44
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
44/70
41
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
45/70
41=1 DERECHO A LA SOLICITUD DE SERVIDUMBRE MINERA1
E-/ ?8(/ - ( +/+*5 ( +-+*+ (+- *-+- -8)8-/+-:
46
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
46/70
41=101 Se!&i)m"!e mine!a 'o"!e te!!eno' el E'tao1:
L+- +-+*+- / */+ -5? 8 + - -*+ )* *- -8)*?(- ; -*+- /*+ 8 )(9+ "0 =- )8-/+
5 -/ R5(/+ ?/+ 8 ( S/+* +*5 8 *5-/*+ 8
( )*/ (8*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
47/70
-+(// ( )*+)/*+ -**- ( )*+/+ -*8*
*.
41=14 Se!&i)m"!e Mine!a 'o"!e la ')+e!*i$ie e ot!a'$on$e'ione'1:
E( +-+*+ / ( ?8(/ )* ( 8/+* ( )+-,
-*8*- -+* /**+- -8)*?(- +/*- +-+- *-.
E-/ *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
48/70
CAPITULO IV/ TRABAJO DE CAMPO Y RESULTADOS/
INVESTIGACION JURISPRUDENCIAL SOBRE LA
SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
4-
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
49/70
5101 TRABAJO DE INVESTIGACION 0/
510101 SENTENCIA DEL TRIBUNAL CONSTITUCIONAL N1 22:2:
AATC/
EP1 N1 22:2:AATC
LIMA
MINERA CORIHUAYCO S1A1
SENTENCIA DEL TRIBUNAL CONSTITUCIONAL
E L (+- /8 =- ( - *+ +- ( +- *8+ (T*8( C+-//8+( --, P(+ J8*-+( + --/ (+-
-+*- M5-/*+- A58** R+ P*-/ R; T**; V)*-/
N85/ D=9 V(* A+-/ S>
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
50/70
C+-/ N.Q I II III IV VII ; ; D+ L(; N.Q I II III ; V 8
+@8// /+/(9 )*+/ + ( *- 12000
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
51/70
/*8* ? ?*8* (+- (5=/+- *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
52/70
)+* ( *>/* -/*8/( 8
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
53/70
)8/+ 8 )++ - ((> ( -/+ + - 8/* ( *89 H8;+(+*+ +
+*/- 8 = )+* ( + N*= (+ 8 @, +8*** - )(+ 8 ( ( -*8*
* )+* (+ 8 * +@/+
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
54/70
3ALLA
D(*+ )*+/ ( /+( (* 3UNDADA ( , )*+ ; +-8
+* 8 ( /*+ /8/*+ /58 * ?8(/- (5(- )* )* ( /*>-/+ )=?+ )+* (
/*+
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
55/70
?8+ -*/ ( / -8 9 +
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
56/70
-//- ( /**/+*+ ( R)( / ( *>/* +-
)(+-.
L+- */*+- /- )8-/+- -+ -8/(- la servidumbre civil es ms
amplia que la minera - 8 )*, 8+ )8- ( -*8* (
-/ -+ - 8 -*8* )-+ -/ - +(5/+* /*- -
-* )* ( )*+ +/ -+ -,(+ 8+ -/ 8* -(
( = )( - (/* ( *
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
57/70
5121 TRABAJO DE INVESTIAGACION 2/
512101 SENTENCIA DEL TRIBUNAL CONSTITUCIONAL N1 22>:2>:
PHCTC/
EP1 N1 22>:2>:PHCTC
LIMA NORTE
SONIA MARIA
PATRICIA JARA
Y OTRO
SENTENCIA DEL TRIBUNAL CONSTITUCIONAL
E L (+- 20 =- ( - *( 200" ( S( P** (
T*8( C+-//8+( /5* )+* (+- M5-/*+- L A**+;+ B8+/
C((*5+- ; E/+ C*89 )*+8 ( -58/ -/
ASUNTOR8*-+ 5*+ +-//8+( /*)8-/+ )+* + J+*5 E*-/+
M9 V5- +/* ( *-+(8, ) )+* ( S58 S( P(
)* P*+-+- + R+- L*- ( C+*/ S8)*+* J8-/ L
?+@- 37! -8 ?
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
58/70
C*;((+ )*+ L -
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
59/70
-/8, ( ) 5*-* -8 /*+ /*@+ ; *(9* -8- (+*-
+/- (+ 8 >- ?/ -8- )*++*- ; (/-.
P+* +/*+ (+ / -*/+ ?-+
J8-/ C+(( ?+@- 241.
R(9 ( -/5, -8* ( / - */?, /++- (+-
/*+- -8 5*5+ >- 8 (+- +- + - 8 ( +-, +/+*5 ( )*- ( 8( - 5*/- -)*( ( )*+ +/ ; -,(+ )8 -* /*-?* + (
-8--/+ ( *5 ( )*+ -*/ )+* (+ 8 (+- )*-8/+-
)*+)/*+- *-)/* ( -*8* )-+ -//. A -8 /8*+ (+-
)(9+- / -*/+ ?- 8 ( +/, )*/ ( -*),
8-8?*8/+ (5 )+* (+- *8**/-
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
60/70
,*5+ @8*-+( H8*+
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
61/70
+8- )-- ; /-. A /( ?/+ ( */=8(+ 7 ( *?* L;
N. 26&0& -/( 8 ( 8/(9, /**- )* ( @*+ /-
*- +
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
62/70
3. A( *-)/+ - )*-+ -(* 8 +?+* + (+ -)8-/+ )+*
( */=8(+ 26 ( C,5+ P*+-( C+-//8+( ( -
+*)8- )8 -* /*)8-/ )+* ( )*-+ )*@8 + )+* 8(8* +/*
-8 ?+* - 8 -/ ( - (5* )*/ *)*-/,
(58. A-= ( )*-/ -+ ( / S+ M*= P/* J*
8+
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
63/70
6. E( */=8(+ 2 -+ 11 ( C+-//8, *58( ( *-/+. E-/ ?8(/ +)+*/ ( @*+ ( /*8/+ ius
movendi et ambulandi. E- * -8)+ ( )+-( -)(9*-
8/+/*// ?8, (- )*+)- -- ; -)*+-
)*-+(- (+ (*5+ ; - 8 +, -)-( )* (
(* -**+((+ ( )*-+ /+ 9 8 - )*-/ ++ ( *-/+ )+* )*8- ((-- **/*- /* +/*+- ( -58+ -8)8-/+ - ?-/ )+*
@)(+ ( 8-+ (- -*8*- )-+. S *5+ -
-/8+- ( @*+
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
64/70
!. N+ ( +* 8 8 8 +//+ + ( -*8*
)-+ +-//8; 8 -//8, (5( 8 -/+ -8- *-- ?-/+-. D *?* / ( )*+/,
*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
65/70
* (5( 8 ( +@/+ ( )*+-+ - +*)8- (
*> -* (* )*+/.
AnKli'i' el $a'o $on$!eto
12. E ( )*-/ -+ (+- /-
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
66/70
-/(+ -8 *5(/+ 58+ (+- 8(-
-* (8 )+* ( @8-/ +** ( )*-/ *> -
(* )*+/ )(, ( */=8(+ &1 ( C,5+ P*+-(
C+-//8+(.
P+* -/+- ?8/+- ( T*8( C+-//8+( + ( 8/+* 8 (
+?* ( C+-//8, P+(=/ ( P*
HA RESUELTO
D(** IMPROCEDENTE( - +*)8-.
P8(=8- ; +/?=8-.
SS.
LANDA ARROYO
BEAUMONT CALLIRGOSETO CRU
512121 APRECIACION CRITICA/
E( T*8( +-//8+( / ++ ?8/+ )*)( no siendo
evidentede los actuados obrantes en el presente proceso de hbeas corpus la
existencia de una servidumbre de paso sobre los predios de los
demandados, cuya existencia y validez legal deber ser dilucidada por la
usticia ordinaria, la presente demanda deber se declarada improcedente en
aplicaci!n del art"culo #,$ del %!digo Procesal %onstitucional.
E( /*8( *-8( 8 - (* )*+/ ( )+* 8 + -
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
67/70
* +/**/ (+ /- *-8(/+ ( E)/ N.Q 202
2000 AATC -8-// ( )*/8* 8 + -5 ( I?+* N.Q 1!&
"!MTC /+ )+* ( C++*+* ( D*, C**/*- (
M-/*+ T*-)+*/- C+8+- V ; C+-/*8,
?(-- @8*-)*8( )(/+ )*+)8-/- +*/-. A>-
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
68/70
( )+--+*+ /5 )+-(- )*/)* 58 /) (
)*+-+.
&. E( )*+-+ -*8* * (5( +/ //8(*- +/*-
+-+- 8+ -/- -+)+*/ ( 5* )8- )* (
(5-(, -+(+ (+- )*+)/*+- ( /**+ -8)*?( -/> (8+ (
)*+/+ -/*/+.
RECOMENDACIONES
1. S (8* ( (5-(, ( 58= )* +-58* ( -*8*
* ++( >- 5* ( +-+*+ *+ 8
8-/* / 8 ?+* /((+ (+- *-8(/+- ( )(,
( 58=. S (+- *-8(/+- -+ 5/+- - * + - +-58 (
-*8* * ++( )+* +-58/ * - )8 ** ( -*8* * (5(.
2. E ( )*+-+ -*8* * (5( - (8* ( )+--+*+
8+ + -/ )*+)/*+ + 8+ -/ + ((> +-5+ *58(*9* -8
)*+).
3. E ( )*+-+ -*8* * (5( - (8* (+- //8(*- +/*- +-+- 8 - ?/+- + ( 5* )8- (
(5-(, + ( *-)/+.
4. L (5-(, * - -**+((+ ( (+- "0 8+ -
-/ /* ( ++= +( -+ ( *= 8 (-
/- 8 5*+ ;+*- -- )* ( )=- )+* - ( +/+*5,
( +-+*+ *+ -//- /*8+- ++ +/*/+-
6-
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
69/70
-/( /*8/* ; ( ?8(/ )+* -*8* * -
+-//+ ( )*+)/*+ ( /**+ -8)*?( */*+ 8 + - (8* ( )*+-+ -/*/+ ( )+-+* ; ( +-+*+
++ //8(*- ( )*+ + +-, -*/ *-)//.
BIBLIOGRA3A
1. ARANGO CASTRO C(+ D( G-/, I+(* (+-
)*+;/+- I?*-/*8/8*. E?+8 ( -/+* *+ ; )/*,(+. E/+*(
P+/=? U*- J*. E/+*( U*-+ ( R+-*+. B+5+/
C+(+ 2007.
2. ARAN$AMENDI NINACONDOR L+ D-+ ; P*+-+ (
I-/5, J8*=. P** E,. E/+*( A*8-. A*8) P*. 200&.
3. AVENDA'O VALDE$ J+*5 D*
7/26/2019 MONOGRAFIA SERVIDUMBRE MINERA
70/70
6. CUEVA $AVALETA J+*5 L8=-. L I-/5, J8*=. P**
E, M*9+ ( 200!. T*8@((+P*.
7. ISOLA A G*( PALAVECINO F*+ M. T- /8(-
D* BADOSA COLL F**> L S*8*
P*+)/*+ M*: M*( P+- 2000 [1 ED.\
11. ORO$CO DIA$ H/+* M*+ B*- +/+- -+* *: P+/? 8*- J* 1""1.
12. V]SUE$ R%OS A(*/+ L+- *